Chelsea State Bank ad

District Court Judge Dismisses Charges Against Protestors

Tuesday, Washtenaw County District Court Judge Anna Frushour dismissed the charges against about 14 people who were ticketed for impeding traffic while taking part in a Black Lives Matter protest in Chelsea in July.

The judge ruled that the state statute under which the tickets were issued was unconstitutional.

The judge deemed that the state’s traffic law was a “content-based regulation of speech,” one that allows people to impede traffic for a specific charitable reason, but it prohibits others from doing so for political or other reasons.  

So, for example from the motion to dismiss the charges, “The statute is a content-based regulation of speech that specifically allows people to impede traffic if they are soliciting money on behalf of a charitable or civic organization, but makes it illegal for individuals to engage in any other type of constitutionally protected speech that impedes traffic.”  

An example of that would be a protest.

You can watch and listen to the court proceedings by going here. The Chelsea case takes place about an hour into the docket.

https://www.washtenaw.org/1008/Judge-Frushour

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

More News

Michigan State Police awarded five-year lease agreement by Sylvan Board

September 7, 2012

AnnArbor.com: Possible plea deal for Lima Township woman

September 7, 2012

Journal Register Company files Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection

September 6, 2012

The Pointe at Cavanaugh Lake, Sylvan Township’s new party store

September 6, 2012

ClickonDetroit.com: DEA raids Chelsea doctor’s office

September 6, 2012

Debut Great Lakes Sporting Arts Show planned for Sept. 8 in Dexter Township

September 6, 2012

Can you help resident find her missing rings?

September 6, 2012

AnnArbor.com: Democratic candidates hold education press conference in Chelsea

September 5, 2012

Hannah Mahalak has German stories to tell her high school classmates

September 5, 2012

Chelsea Kiwanis to host punt, pass and kick contest on Sept. 14

September 5, 2012

No recount of Sylvan millage vote due to incorrectly sealed ballot bags

September 5, 2012

Get involved in the Home Town Holiday festival planning

September 5, 2012

Read the full length obituary for Bob Daniels

September 4, 2012

11 seniors on the 2012 CHS girls swim and dive team

September 4, 2012

Chelsea High School Marching Band to perform (with guests) on Sept. 19

September 4, 2012

Cozy Corner returns: The Darling Dahlias and the Confederate Rose

September 4, 2012

Two Chelsea Farmers’ Markets looking for one market manager

September 4, 2012

St. Louis Center offers ‘Fitness for Life’ for residents with special needs

September 3, 2012

At the Market: Wednesday, Sept. 5

September 3, 2012

Labor Day: Art Farley en route to 2012 Motorcycle Cannonball Run

September 3, 2012

Faith in Action to benefit from special fundraising dinner

September 3, 2012